Only problem with BMX pedals is a lot of them are 1/2in thread.
I did use V12's Mags for a while , they were indeed reliable and lightweight too, but I think the shape and size suits the smaller foot or at least smaller than an 11.
Might have to go modern and stick with the Flatboys, they really are excellent. Have been offered some Powerplay x-plays, a very interesting shape, but i have no idea of the size or build quality.
Had some of the Tioga ones mentioned on an old bike, but they too are a bit on the small size as were the old LX cage pedals with straps