greenstiles":240ayhgv said:
ferrus i've made all kinds of contraptions over the years to isolate and improve sound with equipment.........sometimes all the effort does nothing at all other times it really really helps and is most rewarding...on occation it makes things worse to say over dampen a CD player.
I've noticed that with CD players particularly. I think the thing is, when you try to dampen casework by placing say books or weights on top, you're not actually absorbing or stopping resonance as much as changing (raising) the frequency it resonates at. With CD players it often seems to quieten the noise floor a bit and bring out detail, but also makes them sound more flat and lifeless with less sparkle - more clinical. After all, manufacturers design/voice their components with these resonances contributing to the sound. Distortions of various kinds can impart a warmth and body to the sound, and removing them can result in disapointing results, esp. on lower end kit - It's one of the reasons vinyl sounds so warm and appealing.
As you say though, you can often make big improvements with isolation etc. It's the one place where I've really experimented over the years- fasinating I reckon, as the effects can be so strange and unpredictable, and unlike elsewhere in hi-fi land the improvements can be had for free! I must have spent hundreds of hours schematically trying different approaches and materials.
What intrigues me most is resonance
dissipation. I find it odd that people are only bothered about isolating their kit; when you isolate a component from external vibration, you're also locking resonance
in! The trick is to give the componant a quiet environment but also 'sink' its emittent resonances. I've found sitting my CD player on a thin oak board -on a bag of buckwheat the most effective!
But as with damping, the diffusion/dissipation approach doesn't work for everything and can make some kit sound worse.
With my speakers, there's so much energy going on. The important thing with speakers is to keep them absolutely still and stable, at a 'microscopic' level - that's if you want them to reproduce the most subtle sounds, acoustic ambience etc. You also wanna isolate their floor-born resonance from the rest of the system. No problem, both are easy to do. But I also wanted to dissipate away some of the massive resonance they produce, which is now stopped from being diffused through the floor. Achieving all this is really hard as the principles are working against each other. The best compromise I've found is to sit them on massive sand bag pillows which they sink into, the pillows are sitting on thick slabs held off the floor by 3 simple wood cones. About 4'' up the sides and back of the speakers I've got sand filled tubes (socks!) which are weighted down with bricks onto the sand bag below. This holds the speakers rock steady, and the sand does a good job of absorbing a lot of the resonance. Not much makes it through the sand bag, slab and cones down to the floor either. And it doesn't look as bad as it sounds, honest!
Fascinating stuff, like I said
...
z z zz zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz