The anti Klein brigade.

@24pouces

Oh wow...one KLEIN frame cracked. Can you please provide whats the average failure rate of KLEIN MTB frames per thousand? Compared to Manitou, Cannondale, later Yetis or other Aluminium manufacturers in general.

Its not about lurid examples from the net or magazines. Its about pure and dry statistics - lets say per thousand - or ten thousand of manufactured frames. How many cracked?

And again: KLEIN frames were definitely not certified as being "prone to cracking". There are many other brands or products that were!

@biker23

Were talking about frames here. And you are arguing like a 14 year old. Just the fact, that neither the boxed fork of KLEIN or FUNK cracked (5 of 1.000) dont make the brand prone to cracking in general.

It is simply "stupid" to take out one fact of a peripheral part that was changed after 1 year and categorize the whole brand as "they crack" and simply stubbornly stick to your argument. *lol*

I am not any kind of "fanboy" of KLEIN. I do have a lot to criticize. But its simply dumb to completely overgeneralize ...

Sorry
Argued like a true 14 year old...
 
Unlikely we will know how many cracked, as most owners with a cracked one ended up offing themselves after realising the bicycle equivalent of Munch's The Scream, which they remortgaged the house for, is kissing the pearly gates
 
Their fragility is definitely a valid reason for not liking them, but I don't think it is the result of poor execution, I think it's a direct result of perfect execution when looking at the intentions of the maker - Super light, super stiff, super responsive race bike, the fragility, just like the lack of comfort is an inevitable by product that comes from achieving all of those aims. These frames aren't susceptible to breaking because of poor workmanship or shoddy welds, but because durability was eschewed in the quest for speed. The fragility and lack of comfort are the price that must be paid for owning a bike that has been uncompromisingly engineered right at the cutting edge, if Klein was guilty of anything it was of pushing the envelope too far, of flying too close to the sun.

I didn't enjoy the Klein the first time I took it out, I noticed the speed and responsiveness and appreciated those things, but the way I'd set it up was wrong, the narrow slick daily commute wheelset that I was so familiar with certainly gave me the ability to make accurate comparisons with my other bikes, and it allowed the bike to showcase it's extraordinary qualities, both the good and the bad, but it didn't do the Klein any favours, I have never found a bike so brutally uncomfortable.
View attachment 645800

After that I made my biggest mistake yet and put on my favourite wider rims with fast rolling 2.2's, the Klein took on an altogether more friendly persona, it became much more comfortable while retaining most of the characteristics that set it apart, those traits that make it more likely to snap, and something amazing happened, I can't stop riding it. Like most of us here I've been bike mad since I was a kid, I love cycling and do it at every opportunity, I haven't driven to work in more than 3 years and as long as I'm working within cycling range I'll never drive to work again. I've had plenty of bikes that I especially enjoyed riding, the White Spider, the Fat Chance which is still my favourite smile generating machine, but I have never before been compelled to turn my 20 minute commute home into a string of consecutive one and a half hour treks. Well, since I put the Snow cats on the Klein I have taken the longest route home from work every day, despite the heat and despite the nature of my job which can be described as physically laborious. I can't get enough of it.

View attachment 645805
Now that puts me in a bit of a quandary, I bought the bike because it was in mint condition and relatively cheap, my intention - and I have no qualms admitting this - was to ride it just to experience a Klein, then to carefully box it up and stick it on fleabay for 2-3 times what I paid for it, knowing that someone somewhere would be willing to pay silly money for an almost box fresh example of a 1991 bike.

Well, now it's being ridden hard on a daily basis, one or two tiny chips have already been collected, the shiny smooth teeth on the barely ridden chainrings are becoming scratched, in other words the potential resale value is dropping with each and every pedal stroke. But I don't care, the experience is worth it and I won't care if and when it snaps. In fact I'm having so much fun tearing around the tracks, trails and quiet backstreets that take me the long way home that I can't think of a better way to go should the worst happen, let it fail catastrophically as I fly across the Carlsberg bridge, surely that's a better way to go than by way of a heart attack in my bed.
Wholeheartedly agree with this post, they were made to be ridden & while it's fantastic that people out there preserve them I unashamedly will always use my bikes as.. well, bikes. OK mine are not ever likely to be high value, the most I've ever paid for a bike is £300 for my LTS2000 DH bike & that's only because it matched exactly what I wanted BITD (although having "met my hero" it'll be changing from hereon in) but if I ever came across a BOLX/Yo Eddy/any kind of Klein then they'd get the same treatment.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top