15-20 minutes in oven cleaner will strip the ano, leaving a sort of black powdery finish. this rubs of easily with a scourer or brillo pad
these middleburns spent 20 mins in oven cleaner then about 15 minutes gently with a brillo pad.
i would usually go through the wet and dry grades depending on scratches finishing with 1500 -2000 grit then finish with autosol.
these cranks are being polished by machine though, by Jerry Thurston who has offered his services in this departement for trades i belive.
dont leave in oven cleaner too long as the aluminium will pit
i have also used fine grade wire wool that can be got from b and q and the like with good results for the nooks where its too hard to get wet and dry into