Score draw
Sheesh... that was a hard one! Have gone with 'the bike I'd most like in my cellar/most memorable if I shut my eyes' approach - as there are so many ways in which one could choose how to select a BOTY.
Third place goes to Rumpfy's JT Replica - more for its representation of a key element of our fledgling 'craft', for painstakingly hunting those jigsaw pieces, than its JT connections. I guess it also displays the US leanings towards benchmark replicas and profound historical accuracy - which could be considered cultural paradox, when us Brits are seemingly expressing an artistic or aesthetic approach to our recreations. It would be great to post this selection on MTBR for a Stateside poll and reaction....
Incidentally, I don't get how a single guy (even JT) can get to represent mountain biking - seems a zillion miles away from the sports' folk beginnings - I blame the marketing department...
My second place is Ameybrook's Wicked - so classy and individual a build, it just keeps on growing on me.
And first goes to Felix's Funk - thoroughly outrageous in a Klein-beating way, with that early 90's jaw-dropping, boutique engineering, elevated stuff all going on to define the period when offroad bike designers began to explore the limits of what's possible (and not...), what'd sell and what would make them all go broke...!
Interesting to note how some 'big' bikes are scoring with the benefit of the long view too...
Mr K