It is a bit like the classic cars versus modern cars discussion. Aficionado versus practical daily use. Yes you can do the supermarket run with both but a modern car is much easier. There is no versus in this discussion I think.
My mountainbike collection includes models from the early nineties, noughties and modern bikes today. Funnily enough, nowadays I ride more than I ever did and that’s because of the very cool bikes they produce now. It is amazing how much abuse a modern day bike can handle. I love the modern hardtail I have as it is so quick and handles like a BMX. I love my carbon Stumpjumper Evo because it gets me everywhere I want to go.
As a result, I ride my retrobikes less and less and I’m slowly converting them in pieces of art that I admire. I’d love to own an original paint Adroit or Attitude but I haven’t found one I thought was worth the asking price. If I get one, it will hang on the wall and sees daylight maybe once a year.